I did a full review of InMotion Hosting, which you can read here. However, I wanted to specifically look at InMotion Hosting vs. HostGator. I use an InMotion VPS server to host this website, which used to be hosted on a HostGator server. But I also use HostGator as my primary side-project company due to their pricing. In other words, I use both, they work well and want to compare them head to head to highlight the best fit for new customers.
HostGator has been one of the fastest growing web hosts since 2002. They’ve built their reputation on good pricing, fast servers, and great service. They were acquired by Endurance International (a holding company for several other popular hosting brands including Bluehost & iPage) in 2012. I’ve been a HostGator customer for quite a while, and I currently run most of my development and personal projects on a HostGator shared hosting plan.
And InMotion is a rapidly growing, but still independent hosting company out of Los Angeles that has generated a good bit of press and won several awards for their hosting services. ShivarWeb.com currently lives on an InMotion VPS server.
Like I’ve said in all my hosting reviews and hosting quizzes – there is no such thing as a “best overall host” – there’s only the right host for you given your priorities, resources, and expertise. I’m a long time customer of both companies – and I even use each depending on the demands of each project. I’ve decided to compare InMotion with HostGator across 6+ considerations that hopefully will help you find the right fit for you.
That said – let’s dive in and look at InMotion Hosting vs. HostGator Web Hosting.
You can check out InMotion Hosting’s current Business plans here.
You can check out HostGator’s current shared hosting plans here.
Aside – I am comparing their shared hosting plans (HostGator just calls it “web hosting” and InMotion calls it “business class hosting”), but it’s the same product. Both companies also have excellent website builder products (Gator and Website Creator for HostGator and InMotion, respectively) in addition to VPS and managed WordPress hosting plans.
Either way, with shared hosting, Plan per plan, HostGator appears to be a shade cheaper (with a discount). But hosting pricing is notoriously complicated. It’s hard to compare apples to apples without keeping a few things in mind.
First – HostGator has more billing flexibility. You can sign up for as short as a month or as long as 3 years depending on your needs. InMotion requires you to sign up for at least a year, or a 2nd for a further discount.
Second – it’s easy to quickly scan through the feature checklist – they are, of course, engineered to build value and sell the plan. However, the primary feature that you need to look at to figure out value – and best fit for your goals – are databases, disk space, and websites (domains) allowed.
These are the core part of what you are paying for. If hosting were a car, those would be the engine, and everything else is like the cupholders and seat covers.
Web hosts simply own the server where the files of your website live. Its job is to deliver those files to whoever requests them as fast as possible, every time they ask for them. So here’s a quick run through of definitions. Databases are where the information that makes up your website is stored. The number of databases allowed is roughly how many “websites” you can have on your server.
Websites (the lingo on InMotion) or domains (the lingo on HostGator) refers to the number of domain names that you can route to your hosting account. Confusingly, this is different than databases because you can have infinite distinct websites on 1 “website” or domain. For example, you could have blog.yourdomain.com and yourdomain.com – that would be 1 domain/website…but actually be 2 websites and run off 2 databases. Make sense?
So HostGator’s Hatchling plan allows 1 domain, but unlimited databases. If you were building an event site – you could use this plan and have 2013.yourdomain.com, 2014.yourdomain.com etc, etc. InMotion’s cheapest plan allows 2 “websites” and 2 databases – so you are limited to 2 websites.
HostGator’s Baby & Business plans both offer unlimited domains & databases while InMotion Hosting caps both on all its plans (we’ll get into what that means in Features). On the flip side, InMotion’s cheapest plan is only $1/mo than HostGator and allows 2 sites instead of 1.
HostGator is broadly cheaper than InMotion – especially if you are planning on running several sites on your account. For example – I have several small sites that don’t need a lot of resources or attention – but do need their own databases/domains. I’ve got many of those on HostGator. But for my main sites that require resources and attention – they are all on InMotion.
That said – at renewal pricing, HostGator is only a dollar per month (or less) cheaper than InMotion on the most common plans. If you are planning on only running a site or two, then taken with discounts – InMotion is basically at par with HostGator.
Even though databases, storage, and domains allowed are the key features that you should use to make sure you’re comparing apples to apples – other features, of course, do matter.
In general, web hosting companies do a great job at simply repeating and re-emphasizing the same features in different ways so that you come away with the perception that one is different…when really they just re-framed a standard feature in a certain way.
For example, HostGator has an annoying habit of emphasizing features that really aren’t features.
And InMotion has a habit of getting technical with no context or throwing around marketing jargon.
Explaining every feature would take 20,000 very boring words, so instead here’s a brief rule of thumb that you can use to compare.
First – InMotion has a much broader array of meaningful features than HostGator. InMotion supports all sorts of programming languages out of the box that HostGator does not provide. This didn’t use to be the case, but ever since 2013, HostGator has continually underinvested in new features while InMotion has continually added new ones (even if they are super-technical).
As I found out with one of my side projects, InMotion does not preemptively regulate your site for resource usage as much as HostGator. In my example, I have a low traffic site with functionality that uses the database to create a dynamic redirect. It would not be usable at high traffic levels, but for low traffic, it’s fine. It got locked out on HostGator but was good to go on InMotion.
Second – they both provide free automated backups. InMotion provides the restore for free; HostGator charges for the restore.
Third – HostGator does a lot more feature integrations and cross-sells than InMotion. For some, that’s a good thing. For others, not so good. I personally like to have clean installations of my software before adding to them, but others like bundled products (ie, your WordPress install comes preloaded with themes and plugins).
Lastly – they both allow for unlimited email usage at all tiers and they both integrate with Google Apps.
On raw features – InMotion provides a better product with more versatility than HostGator. That said, HostGator’s features are great for a basic, useful website(s).
One of the core functions of your hosting account is to deliver your website to every visitor as quickly as possible – every time someone asks for it.
There are a lot of factors that go into how quickly your website loads – and much of it relates to how your website is configured. But one of the biggest factors is how well your hosting account can perform.
For shared hosting, one metric that you can look at to judge performance is Time to First Byte (TTFB). This measures the time from when your website first gets a request to when it acknowledges the request and starts to return the data.
Imagine you go to a warehouse and walk up to a stock picker. TTFB is how long it takes for him to take your slip, read it, and start running to get your stuff. The stuff may be scattered everywhere in the warehouse – and it might be super huge, but the time it takes for him to just get going is still critical.
Here are the results I got by testing a site that I have on HostGator and a test site I have on InMotion’s shared hosting with the same setup each. I tested both with the same software from the same requesting server. TTFB is the first metric you see.
InMotion Speed Test:
HostGator Speed Test:
It’s close – and they are both above average for shared hosts. Historically, I’ve found InMotion to be consistently better.
The other part of the performance equation is that your hosting account must deliver your site every time someone asks for it – otherwise known as “uptime.”
They both advertise 99.9% uptime. I’ve never had a problem with either – and have never experienced significant downtime on my websites ever with HostGator in my several years as a customer.
Looking through InMotion forum posts – it looks like its a metric that they historically take very seriously. They had several hours of downtime on May 4th, 2017 – something that I covered in my main InMotion review.
One situation that gives InMotion Hosting an edge in this area is the Endurance Group International event of August 2013. In 2012, HostGator was purchased by Endurance Group International – a holding company for many other brands such as Bluehost and Just Host and iPage.
Each brand is run independently, but they have all been slowly merging infrastructure to cut costs. In August 2013, a large portion of HostGator’s infrastructure was migrated to the Provo, Utah data center…and ended causing quite a SNAFU. Actually – a really bad SNAFU that hurt all of Endurance’s brands. Some websites were down completely for more than 3 days, and not a ton of information was forthcoming from Endurance corporate.
HostGator still claims that they aim for and achieve 99.99% uptime outside of the isolated incident. I personally stuck with HostGator for most of my sites, since I figured that it was an incident that Endurance will learn from and that even the biggest data providers hit trouble occasionally (ie, including both Google & Amazon – and Facebook as recently as this month).
However, a lot of people were really frustrated with the industry, and it’s something that certainly benefits independently run hosting companies like InMotion Hosting (and something that drove HostGator’s growth until it was acquired).
On consistently good performance – I still feel more comfortable with InMotion despite their past downtime events.
A hosting account should not require a degree in computer science, but it also shouldn’t be limiting to customers who can find their way around. And that’s where usability comes in.
It’s a tough line to walk between being super-easy for first-time users and allowing regular users to find the information they want and make the changes they need.
InMotion Hosting and HostGator both run their backends on the exact same platform – cPanel, which is industry standard, open-source, and though it’s not very pretty – and can be a bit daunting for first timers – it’s fairly straightforward to operate. There’s tons of documentation and tutorials for it as well. Here’s what HostGator looks like…
Here’s what InMotion looks like –
Both have fairly clean designs. However, InMotion has less clutter and fewer upsells. They also have a clean WordPress autoinstall.
Where HostGator and InMotion differ is in their account management & software bundling.
When you sign up for HostGator, you get a login for your billing/account management and then you get your direct login info for your cPanel hosting account. Two sites – pretty distinct purposes. Here’s a HostGator email for example – note the billing system link.
InMotion gives you access to your Account Management Panel, which serves as your hosting account frontend, your billing area, and the place you go to get into your cPanel.
They advertise it as an easier setup. In 2013, I found it to be quite confusing when I first logged in – partly because it has a good many upsells, and I couldn’t find some very specific information that, as an advanced user, I really wanted immediately.
InMotion has dramatically improved their backend in the past few years though.
Here’s a shot of their Account Management Panel…
Both HostGator and InMotion have simple QuickInstall functionality for software like WordPress, Joomla, etc. The one thing that HostGator has changed is software bundling.
When you do a WordPress QuickInstall, HostGator automatically installs their theme marketplace software with WordPress. Some people might find that convenient – and some might find it annoying. Here’s what it looks like (from a recent site setup – ignore the markup).
See the “MOJO Marketplace”? – that’s HostGator software. You can uninstall it from the Plugins sections easily enough. Nevertheless, it’s not ideal from my perspective.
I’d say that InMotion wins the usability category. I like HostGator’s minimalism, but InMotion’s single account management is also very convenient – and the zero QuickInstall add-ons reduce bloat in my opinion.
Customer service often gets overlooked when choosing hosting companies. It’s easy to not factor it in because it’s hard to imagine the problems that might come up.
The thing is that when you need customer support, you often really need it.
However, the problem with rating customer service is that almost all reports are anecdotal – and typically it’s the bad experiences that get reported more often while outstanding service is taken as typical. No one has a “big picture” view of customer service levels except the companies themselves…who, of course, bias towards their own awesomeness.
I’ve had readers of this original review email me with bad experiences from both HostGator and InMotion. I’ve had readers tell me about great experiences they’ve had with both. A lot of people say that HostGator hasn’t been the same since Endurance International bought them.
So I tried to look for a “proxy” to judge which direction the companies’ cultures are going. The proxy I looked at was their Knowledgebase – where users can go to research and do DIY troubleshooting.
From everything I see, InMotion consistently invests more in keeping their Knowledgebase up to date than HostGator. InMotion actually treats their knowledgebase as a support channel where they use a topic to kick off a conversation with customers about questions that aren’t even directly related to their hosting account.
InMotion Knowledgebase – End of W3 Total Cache Article:
HostGator Knowledgebase (Same article as InMotion Example)
The HostGator article in this example is fine. You could install the WordPress plugin with it. But InMotion goes further. Their piece includes screenshots and timely responses to comments, which in many cases provide more clarity than the original piece.
InMotion has dramatically invested in this area in the past few years. They now rank in Google for a huge swath of technical issues for non-InMotion customers.
Additionally, I’ve found InMotion to be more willing to solve software problems that technically aren’t their problem whereas HostGator will point me in the right direction while still leaving me up to myself.
For example, I had an issue with my WordPress install timing out when uploading media. It was a WordPress problem (aka my problem) but InMotion not only provided direction but actually gave me the code to implement. When confirming with HostGator, they were able to point me to a tutorial, but not the actual code. Both were fine – but InMotion seems to go a bit further.
As with features & usability – HostGator is fine. They do things well compared to many providers, but InMotion goes a bit beyond.
There are of course other factors that come into play when looking at hosting providers. These are kind of a grab bag, but they should at least be known.
For better or worse, InMotion Hosting is independently owned, and HostGator is owned by a big corporation. InMotion does a lot of WordPress event sponsorship – that’s cool. HostGator has been around for a long time and has won a lot of awards & press.
InMotion Hosting offers web design services – I think that that is odd, and not related to their core competency of hosting, but it also can be a convenient feature for some customers.
If you are doing many integrations – I (and several readers) have found InMotion to be more flexible with getting integrations right.
For example, I’ve had complex apps that I wanted on my site. They were blocked by HostGator by default. It took quite a bit of work to get it fixed, whereas InMotion provided direct access to my php.ini file along with support to get it right.
I’ve had two readers mention HostGator’s issues with Google Apps. Now that’s only if you also have your domain with them, but it does fit with the general story.
InMotion offers free, integrated Comodo SSL certificates that make it simpler to go HTTPS rather than HostGator’s shared certificates.
They both offer virtual private servers, dedicated servers, and WordPress hosting if your site ever needs an upgrade in resources. They both offer website builders with InMotion’s built on top of WordPress and HostGator’s being a native drag & drop builder.
Here’s the deal – I try to never declare a “best” choice in any hosting review. Different products and providers can be a better fit for different people depending on their goals. That said, both HostGator or InMotion Hosting are good choices. I actively use them for my websites. I recommend them both to clients depending on the clients’ needs.
I think that if you are only going to be working with 1 or 2 websites, have a slightly more flexible budget, don’t mind pre-paying for a year, and you are focused on worry-free features (such as free data backup) and customer service – then you should check out InMotion Hosting here.
If you are going be operating several websites, and/or you are mainly focused on good performance on a budget, and/or need monthly billing then HostGator is going to be a better fit for you.
If you plan on using WordPress – you might also be interested in my WordPress Website Setup Guide here – I use InMotion for the screenshots, but they also work for HostGator as well.
Lastly, if you still aren’t quite sure, check out my simple, fun hosting quiz to figure out the best fit for your project.
Good luck with your project!