There are a lot of options for running an online store – Shopify is an all-in-one eCommerce solution that I’ve used to run several online stores & consult with clients since 2009. Here’s my Shopify review – with 6 pros and 6 cons of using Shopify for your online store.
You can check out Shopify’s current Plans & Pricing here.
EDIT 01/12/2018: This Shopify review was originally published 7/13/2013 and re-published frequently with updates to reflect new features/pricing/opinion. From 2016 through 2018, Shopify has improved on several fronts, especially with a much-improved checkout process. Just in the last year, they added same domain checkout – previously a big disadvantage.
But first, a bit of intro.
There’s a lot of options for running an online store, and your choice of best eCommerce platform can have just as big of an effect on your business as choosing a building or location for a physical store. It’s not the end all of the business – but it certainly can make or break your business – and can either expand your opportunity or severely kneecap your business.
What Is Shopify?
Shopify is part of a group of turn-key eCommerce (aka “hosted eCommerce”) solutions that provide everything you need from end to end (minus the product and business know-how) to set up and start selling your product(s) to the world as opposed to you putting all the pieces together yourself (see Shopify’s plans here).
It’s sort of like hiring a general contractor to build your house, over being the contractor and hiring sub-contractors yourself. You’re still in control, but you let the general contractor use their expertise to make the project happen. My go-to analogy is with real estate.
There are pros and cons to the approach – which is what we’ll get into. But basically know that Shopify competes mainly with BigCommerce and Volusion – all three of which provide turn-key eCommerce solutions, which in turn compete with non-turnkey solutions (like setting up your own store with WordPress).
And these hosted solutions sort of compete and integrate with eCommerce “marketplaces” like Amazon, eBay, and Etsy. I wrote more about how Shopify can work with Etsy here and how Shopify competes with website builders like Wix here.
Aside – Shopify also has a “Buy button” functionality that allows you to use Shopify as Point of Sale (POS) / Inventory option – and let customers click to buy your products anywhere online (Pinterest, Facebook, WordPress blog, Tumblr, etc). I’ll be looking less at that – and more at Shopify’s full online store package. You can get the Buy button only as part of the Lite Plan, but it competes with PayPal rather than full online store options.
So How Does Shopify Work?
Shopify is fairly straightforward – which is sort of their whole selling point. The broad process is as follows –
- Pick a Shopify plan that fits your budget and feature needs.
- “Point” your domain that you bought from a registrar like GoDaddy or NameCheap to your Shopify store. You also buy one via Shopify.
- Choose a design/template for your store. You can edit a free one via their drag/drop tool or buy a premium one or hire a designer.
- Add your products, page content, payment options, etc
- Go get customers! Here’s an eCommerce marketing strategy to get you started.
Make sense? Cool. Let’s dive into the actual Shopify review.
Pros of Using Shopify
There are a lot of Shopify reviews online – usually with user-generated reviews based on anecdotes and personal experience. That’s fine but I take a different approach. I’ve worked with Shopify not only as a store owner but also as a consultant to stores running on Shopify – plus, consulting customers with stores running on platforms ranging from custom built platforms to WooCommerce and dozens of others. There is no such thing as a “best” choice – only the right choice for your store based on your resources and objectives.
Built-in Speed & Security for Hosting
Here are the results of a speed test for my local coffee shop that runs their store on Shopify:
One of the challenges of running an online store is that you have dual needs from your hosting: you need it to be screaming fast and you need it to be super secure if you are processing credit cards.
For every extra tenth of a second that a customer waits for your page to load is a second that they might very well leave and go to your competition. In fact, most studies show that people will only wait up to 4 seconds for a site to load before leaving – and this gets even tighter for eCommerce sites.
On the flip side, you also need to route your customer’s credit cards through extra layers of security to remain PCI compliant and process credit cards. Many stores outsource payments to a third-party vendor (such as PayPal or Google Wallet), but even that connection can be slowed if your store isn’t set up right.
An all-in-one solution like Shopify allows you to turn that side of the business over to the pros and just let them worry about hackers, caching, compliance, and a whole range of issues that come with hosting an online store. Shopify can do things like pay bounties to security researchers to hack-proof their systems. Shopify is safe and legit. They are a publicly traded company with huge investments in software & security engineering.
There are a ton of factors that go into website speed, but, since Shopify can handle speed & security at a “global” platform level – they can do it especially well. They provide 100% SSL, keep their sites screaming fast, and integrate with payment providers well so that you can always get paid, and customers are never waiting for their page to load.
All The Necessary Features
Whether you are building your own eCommerce solution or shopping for an all-in-one solution, getting all the pieces of an online store together can actually be a bit challenging.
Sure, you can strip the bare bones down to having a product up to buy, and allow someone to pay and give you their information – but to do it right – you’re going to want other features on top.
You’re going to want integrated payments; you ‘re going to want an easy way to add and remove products; you’re going to want to be able to customize the look of your store; and you’re definitely going to want to have solid, easy to implement analytics to track everything (something that Volusion makes it tough to implement).
Whenever I have run stores for clients or myself in the past, Shopify had everything I needed to run an amazing online store – without being nickel and dimed in upgrades or left out to dry without a key feature.
Great Customer Support
When I contrast my experiences between building an eCommerce store myself (with something like WordPress + WooCommerce) and running it with something like Shopify – customer support is one of my top reasons to go with something like Shopify.
When you are building it and running it yourself – you have no one to turn to, except $$$ developers and often unresponsive online forums. With Shopify – you get answers fast. And all my customer support experiences with Shopify have been really fast, correct, and helpful – from both a developer and storeowner perspective.
They have a huge database of FAQs, email/chat support…and phone support – with a real, knowledgeable rep on the other side.
When you are focused on running your online store – this safety net of always having someone at your back with answers is basically worth the Shopify subscription price alone. And on this point, Shopify especially shines.
What good is an online store if you can’t get anyone to show up? That’s what marketing is for – and it’s something that Shopify really excels at. Shopify doesn’t offer the fanciest marketing tools on the planet (as part of the main package – they offer more in the App Marketplace) – but they do include the essentials – and they make sure they do the essentials really well. For example, SEO:
For marketing campaigns (such as email, AdWords, etc), Shopify allows you to quickly and easily create landing pages, which is a key differentiating factor between other all-in-one platforms (and some DIY platforms).
And for SEO – Shopify creates 100% crawlable, clean code. They allow custom Title tags, and meta descriptions (see screenshot) – even on collections, in addition to other essentials like Search Console, sitemaps, and the prevention of the perennial bane of eCommerce SEO…duplicate content (for SEO geeks, they use canonicals properly).
Even though they don’t allow “root” or FTP access, as an SEO consultant, I’ve always been able to implement even technical items via their front-end code editor. Or – they actually already have all the advanced technical items done for me (e.g., Schema, SSL, Canonicals, Sitemaps, etc) so that I can focus on things like content strategy.
If you’re looking for an all-in-one platform that does good marketing for SEO, AdWords, and anything else up your sleeve – Shopify is a great choice in my experience.
I think that good web platforms should always offer at least 3 levels of customization: first, it should look fine out of the box; second, it should be easily improvable without having to employ and professional graphic designer or developer.
WordPress is a good example for this – it looks great out of the box; it has tons of custom themes that you can buy and apply, but it also has the ability to be wielded by a professional designer to create a really high-end website.
Shopify has this ability as well, and I give a huge pro to Shopify for that. Shopify runs off a theme system. It has free themes bundled out of the box to choose from, and a wide variety of custom-built themes to purchase through their marketplace. In addition, as you can see in the screenshot above, Shopify makes its theme system available so that a designer or developer can customize it and create any type of shop you want – whether you are a tiny niche boutique or a multi-million dollar enterprise.
If you are just starting, you can make do just fine with a free theme and upgrade as you can justify/need it.
Add-Ons (Shopify App Store + Buy Button)
Shopify comes with a ton of features built-in, but no platform can possibly accommodate all the features needed by storeowners – so Shopify took a page from Facebook, Apple, and Android by starting an App Store.
Shopify provides the platform and all the core features, plus it allows developers to offer hyper-specialized products that plugin seamlessly to Shopify’s platform.
Some are paid and some are free. The Chimpified App is my favorite example though. Not all retailers need or do email marketing, but some love it. It’s not a core feature of Shopify – but MailChimp (an awesome email marketing company) built an App that integrates MailChimp seamlessly with Shopify. It’s free and awesome.
With this setup – you don’t have to worry about finding a developer every time you want a certain feature because it’s probably in the App Store…and will be a lot cheaper and will work exactly as advertised.
And over the past year, this has turned into one of Shopify’s “killer features” that puts them ahead of much of their direct competition. So many companies integrate directly with Shopify that it’s straightforward to purchase the right solution for whatever you need (ie, for email, retargeting, CRM, etc).
Additionally, Shopify has really invested in their Buy button. On one hand, it’s a bit confusing to sell product separate from your website. On the other hand, it adds a lot of flexibility for brands that have a presence all around the web – or for merchants that just don’t want to set up a full online store on a domain.
Not all platforms have the scale to pull this off correctly, but Shopify does – and they have a business development team that specifically works on developing new apps and bringing new developers to solve problems. The App Store is a huge pro for me with Shopify.
Cons of Using Shopify
Not every platform is perfect though, and a Shopify review wouldn’t be complete without covering the cons of using Shopify for an online store. Let’s dive into the 6 cons of using Shopify for eCommerce.
If you have a small online store – Shopify is going to be more expensive than BigCommerce at the beginning, and get more affordable as you grow. The kicker isn’t the $5 difference – it’s the transaction fees that Shopify charges (which are on top of any credit card feed). They justify it by pointing out that they go away as you grow – but it still represents a bit of a barrier to entry for Shopify. They ameliorate some of the pricing by offering the “Get Started” option at $14/mo – but to me the transaction fees come off as a con of using Shopify, especially since you may not be sure about your sales volume or profitability at the start. If you want a small online store – and plan on staying small, then you might want to also check out BigCommerce (just don’t go with Volusion because of their Analytics issues). But otherwise, it’s not a deal breaker for most online store owners – but is a con to be aware of and plan for.
In 2014, Shopify restructured their pricing in line with new industry business models. To put their pricing in context and help you decide between competitors (like Bigcommerce – review here or Volusion – review here), here’s a rundown of 4 elements of pricing you should consider.
First, your monthly price – the sticker price you pay every month for a certain level of features. Shopify’s plans start with the Lite Plan at $9 USD per month and go up from there. But note that the Lite plan is only for Buy button sellers. Really, I’d say that Shopify starts at $29/mo and goes up.
Second, your platform transaction fees – the additional fee you pay to a platform as a percent of sales. Shopify used to charge these on all their plans, but no longer does. You should pay attention to these when cross-comparing.
Third, your credit card fees – these used to be pretty standardized – and for the most part still are. However, Shopify recently set up their own POS & processing network so you don’t have to go through a 3rd party processor. That means fees go to Shopify rather than a processor like PayPal or Authorize.net. It can be confusing, and there are some lock-in issues to consider with Shopify. But be sure you are comparing apples to apples.
Fourth, your add-on fees – these are 3rd party apps, plugins or bits of software that you can purchase to make your store better. Usually, these are one-time purchases, but sometimes they run off transaction fees. Shopify has a huge app store. Many are free, but some are paid. Be sure to budget for these when planning your store.
Pricing is a “con with a caveat” for Shopify. The built-in credit cards & no transaction fees are huge, but monthly price & add-on fees can add up. Basically, Shopify is slightly pricier than Volusion & slightly cheaper than Bigcommerce as a general rule…unless you lockin to Shopify Payments – at which point the scales can tip back. The price differences are close enough that you should be comparing based on features & service.
Shopify, like all hosted platforms, is going to be consistently more expensive month to month than a self-hosted store you run yourself. However, self-hosted stores (like WordPress + WooCommerce) tend to have really $$$ development needs occasionally – especially if you’re running a bigger setup.
If you have some technical know-how and a smaller shop, Shopify pricing will be expensive. If you want to focus on running & marketing your store (and prefer known monthly costs), then Shopify’s pricing will actually be an incredible value. You don’t have to hire developers or a technically savvy SEO consultant to take care of things like Google Merchant Center or Schema.
Hacking around customization
I made the point earlier that a pro of Shopify is that it looks good out of the box, has great custom themes available, and has the ability to be fully customized by a developer/designer.
Now to the con of their customization setup – they use a unique setup to customize their themes versus using something like PHP for their templates. It’s a huge plus in some ways, but for someone who loves to tweak things without doing a full-on customization, it can be annoying.
I’m used to tweaking WordPress templates because they are in PHP – which is a common language and thus has tons of forums and support, while the Shopify Liquid setup is a bit foreign to me and any other first-timers.
It is fairly straightforward to pick up, and they do offer amazing support in the Shopify forums, but I still consider it a bit of a con to have to become familiar with Liquid to tweak my store’s theme.
Content marketing is a huge marketing medium for eCommerce. You can boost your organic traffic, increase social shares, grow your brand, and educate your customers.
Shopify comes with built-in blogging software…but it’s not the greatest – especially if you are spoiled for WordPress. It gets the job done, and it’s better than it’s competitor’s options, but is definitely something I’d love to see improved upon.
My rule of thumb is that if you run a blog that now has a store – then adding WooCommerce to WordPress makes sense. But – if you are primarily an online store with a blog as a marketing tool, then Shopify works well.
Every eCommerce platform is going to have a learning curve, but I found that Shopify has a slightly steeper curve just because the jargon they use is slightly off. Whether it’s their Liquid theme setup, using “collections” over “categories”, or various other small edits – I find their store setup to be not exactly how I’d set things up.
It’s not a huge con – but other solutions like BigCommerce are a bit more straightforward with their “user experience.” This con is much improved though with the release of Shopify 2 (as seen in the initial setup video below) – but is still there.
Lock-in is something I had to include in my Shopify review, even though it is a con for all-in-one eCommerce in general. Here’s the deal – if you ever decide to move your store to a different platform – it’s not going to be smooth. This makes choosing an eCommerce platform especially tricky because you have to plan for the future – and not just consider costs right now.
In my opinion, Shopify is an amazing platform to grow with. They have the scale, features, support, and pricing to cover you whether you are a brand new 1 product shop – or if you want to be the next Amazon.
However, if you were to ever want to leave, the best you could get would be a CSV export of your product information. Everything else – gone. It’s the same with BigCommerce, Volusion, and any “hosted eCommerce platform”, but it’s still a con to consider when looking for an online store platform.
The last con of using Shopify for your online store is their initial setup process. With the release of Shopify 2 – Shopify has definitely made initial setup of your online store much easier – but it still isn’t a “just add water” step by step. It’s easy in a sense, but I think they oversell it a bit. It requires a little bit of technical know-how (especially to get your domain name redirecting correctly).
For anyone who buys into Shopify expecting to be making money in 15 minutes is going to be disappointed. The reason it takes a bit longer and requires a bit of technical knowledge is that Shopify does do it right, and doesn’t allow you to cut corners – and they don’t make real decisions for you. However – to round up the last con – here’s a video tour of the Shopify backend so that you can see for yourself. The video is a few months old, but the general layout & feel are the same as now.
Shopify Review Conclusion
If you are looking for an all-in-one eCommerce solution for your online store, and you are looking to grow and add products – and you have a little bit of technical know-how, then Shopify will be a great fit for you.
If you are looking for something a little bit cheaper, and a little bit easier to setup – then I would also consider BigCommerce (see their plans here & see my Bigcommerce review here). Take my eCommerce platform quiz here that will help you decide.
If you have any comments, questions, or experiences – let me know in the comments!
EDIT: Due to the extraordinary amount of spam this post attracts, I’ve disabled comments. Talk to me via Twitter!